I Watch Films: Wuthering Heights (2026)
Wuthering Heights (2026)
Mr Earnshaw (Martin Clunes) brings back a boy, Heathcliff (as an adult Jacob Elordi), to his remote farm on the moors, Wuthering Heights. He’s given a leaky barn to live in*, and becomes the inseparable companion of Mr Earnshaw’s daughter Catherine (as an adult Margot Robbie). Cathy’s companion Nelly Dean (Hong Chau) is somewhat suspicious of Heathcliff, wanting Cathy to prepare herself for marriage to someone suitable.
Suitable? As they reach adulthood the farm falls into disrepair as Mr Earnshaw turns to gambling and drink. Cathy courts their neighbour Edgar Linton, hoping to turn the farm around with his money, and introduce Heathcliff to better society so he can make a success of himself. Spraining her ankle Cathy is taken in by Edgar and his ward Isabella. Edgar proposes marriage, and she accepts.
Confessing her mixed feelings to Nelly Dean, as she loves Heathcliff, she lashes out telling Nelly she doesn’t understand as she can’t love. In response Nelly goads her, knowing Heathcliff is listening in, and Cathy admits that marrying him would be degrading. She changes her mind, but by then Heathcliff has left the farm.
Cathy marries Edgar who creates a lavish and stylish home for her at Thrushcross Grange. Five years later Heathcliff returns, rich and cultured. Heathcliff is bitter, jealous and consumed with the need to take revenge. He buys Wuthering Heights from the decrepit Mr Earnshaw, who shortly after dies. He starts an affair with Cathy, who reveals she is pregnant. He claims this is nothing to him, though Nelly reveals the affair to Edgar who forbids Cathy seeing him. He offers to kill Edgar which she refuses. He marries Isabella, treating her like an animal (Isabella seems to understand and accept his behaviour and motivations).
Cathy locks herself in her room, starving herself. Heathcliff sends letters but Nelly intercepts them, so Cathy thinks herself abandoned. She miscarries, and infection sets in. Realising that things have gone too far Nelly heads to Wuthering Heights to inform Heathcliff, and rescue Isabella. Heathcliff frantically rides to the Grange to find Cathy dead; he insists that she haunt him and drive him insane to punish him for what he’s done.
This adaption does not merely neglect the second generation and frame story of Wuthering Heights, it cuts all that out, along with the characters required for it. Similarly the period setting is given magnificent, glorious, colour-coded and thematically designed attention rather than sticking to likely or best attested versions. And it highlights the foolish, magnificent self- and other-destructive impulses that drive Cathy, Heathcliff, Isabella, Mister Earnshaw, and most of all Nelly Dean. An adaption that is untrue to the novel, yet captures something at the heart of it in a bonkers tragedy.
Watch This: Magnificent looking romantic tragedy
Don’t Watch This: Overwrought melodrama wringing only the
bitterest flavours from the novel
* No one fixes the roof over the ten or so years this film takes place over. This is a deliberate choice, and tells you something. It fails at creating the feeling that this as a real place, a real farm, inhabited by real people who work on real things, and that also tells you something about this film.
_poster.png)

Comments